Can You Skillfully Ski the Slopes?

Riddler Classic

Congratulations, you’ve made it to the finals of the Riddler Ski Federation’s winter championship! There’s just one opponent left to beat, and then the gold medal will be yours.

Each of you will complete two runs down the mountain, and the times of your runs will be added together. Whoever skis in the least overall time is the winner. Also, this being the Riddler Ski Federation, you have been presented detailed data on both you and your opponent. You are evenly matched, and both have the same normal probability distribution of finishing times for each run. And for both of you, your time on the first run is completely independent of your time on the second run.

For the first runs, your opponent goes first. Then, it’s your turn. As you cross the finish line, your coach excitedly signals to you that you were faster than your opponent. Without knowing either exact time, what’s the probability that you will still be ahead after the second run and earn your gold medal?

Extra credit: Over in the snowboarding championship, there are 30 finalists, including you (apparently, you’re a dual-sport threat!). Again, you are the last one to complete the first run, and your coach signals that you are in the lead. What is the probability that you’ll win gold in snowboarding?

Solution

Let $y_1$, $o_1$, $y_2$, and $o_2$ represent your and your opponent's 1st and 2nd run times. We know that all four follow the same normal probability distribution. It is given that $y_1 < o_1$.

Let $d_1 = o_1 - y_1$ and $d_2 = o_2 - y_2$ represent how much faster you are than your opponent in each run. The difference of two independent normally distributed variables is also normally distributed.

Finally, let $s = d_1 + d_2$ represent the sum of the difference for both runs. The sum of two independent normally distributed variables is also normally distributed.

The problem can be summarized as the conditional probability that $s > 0$ given $d_1 > 0$.

Case 1 : $d_2 > 0$

You are faster than your opponent in the second run, so $s > 0$ is a certainty. Since $d_2$ is normally distributed, this is $\dfrac{1}{2}$.

Case 2 : $d_2 < 0$

Your opponent is faster than you in the second run. Since $d_2$ is normally distributed, this is also $\dfrac{1}{2}$.

Since $d_1 > 0$ and $d_2 < 0$, $s > 0$ and $s < 0$ both occur with an equal probabilty of $\dfrac{1}{2}$ because of symmetry.

In other words, given your opponent does better in the second run, you will still win the gold $\dfrac{1}{2}$ the time.

Answer

Adding up the two cases yields:

$$\dfrac{1}{2} + \left(\dfrac{1}{2} \right) ^2 = \dfrac{3}{4}$$


Note the runs and results of the winner can be summarized with symmetry. The answer is the teal area in the first row.

Extra Credit

Assuming all 30 finalists are evenly matched, have the same normal probability distribution, and have indepenent first run and second run times, the probability of you winning the gold is:

$$\left(\dfrac{3}{4} \right) ^{30} \approx 0.00018$$

Rohan Lewis

2021.01.24 (Picture Update on 2021.01.26)

Code can be found here.